Book Review: Costume Close Up

Costume Close-Up (1999) by Baumgarten & Weston

 

Another book-review that I keep neglecting to post. Costume Close-Up: Clothing Construction and Pattern, 1750-1790 by Linda Baumgarten and John Weston is a detailed exploration of 25 items of the late 18th century clothing from the Williamsburg Collection. Three are ensembles with multiple components, giving a total of 30 garments featured. 

 

The book itself is 120 pages. It begins with a 6-page introduction which broadly covers 18th century fashionable silhouettes, how to study antique clothing, 18th sewing techniques, and garment terminology. Excepting 2 pages of end-notes, the rest of the book is divided into 25 sections, each investigating one garment or ensemble. Thirty short 'side topics' (each about a paragraph long with an illustration) are scattered throughout the relevant sections to provide context on how the garments/materials were made, what kinds of people worn them, etc. There's also a 5-page spread of color photographs.

 

The different sections each begin with the artifacts' identifying information. Short paragraphs then discuss the garment category, the materials used in this example, any evidence of how this specific garment was altered, and the construction methods present in it. The last category is the longest, with each technique or point of interest getting its own short paragraph. Each garment or outfit has at least two black-and-white photographs (full length and a detail), as well as line-drawings of all its component pieces on a scaled page (in inches & cm). Where relevant, line drawings are also used to show embroidery patterns or particular construction methods. There are one or two asides depending on the item, often accompanied by a contemporary image of similar garments. For example, the #5 quilted petticoat has an aside addressing 'who wore quilted petticoats?' with an 1783 engraving of a woman wearing one, and a second aside on block printing accompanied by a c.1780 print.

Per the authors' introduction, this book is not a manual for sewing 18th century clothing, but was intended as an introduction to studying antique garments. I think that it does this job admirably, while also providing useful information for recreating specific garments. I appreciate the amount of detail that is included, and admire how approachable the authors have made it. I have my copy shelved right next to Patterns of Fashion 1, but I could see myself handing this book to a new researcher or repro sewist where I would hesitate to start someone on PoF.

 

The two things that would make this book even better are more color pictures, and an actual grid on the pattern diagrams. Admittedly, I believe the latter was a deliberate choice, as it allows the scales on the edges to be marked in both metric and standard, but I do personally prefer having the grid when scaling up designs. For the former, Williamsburg has digitized over 1200 items from their costume collection (including every item from this book that I've searched for).

Stars: 5

Accuracy: High. It's all original garments.

Skill Level: Suitable for all levels as a guide to garment study. Advanced for garment recreation (would be need to be comfortable scaling pattern diagrams, fitting, determining work order, etc.) 

Strongest Impression: Really shines on the details. Has the diagrams and descriptions of a Janet Arnold book, but with more pictures and more explanations.